ASHES TO ASHES: Movie review of Cinderella by Howard Casner

First, a word from our sponsors. Ever wonder what a reader for a contest or agency thinks when he reads your screenplay? Check out my new e-book published on Amazon: Rantings and Ravings of a Screenplay Reader, including my series of essays, What I Learned Reading for Contests This Year, and my film reviews of 2013. Only $2.99. http://ow.ly/xN31r

 

and check out my Script Consultation Services: http://ow.ly/HPxKE

 

Warning: SPOILERS

cinderellaThere is one absolutely lovely and magical moment in the new live action, non-musical Disney version of the animated, fully musicalized Disney version of the classic Charles Perrault fairy tale Cinderella.

Our titular character, frustrated and defeated by the cruel treatment at the hands of her step-mother and step-sisters, takes to horse and rides off into a distant woods where she stops the Prince from hunting down a stag.

What’s wonderful about this scene is that the previously optimistic (and rather annoyingly Pollyanish at times) Cinderella is finally the person she really is, beaten down, sad, furious at the circumstances she has found herself in, while the Prince, in turn, is finally the person he isn’t: here he pretends to be a mere apprentice and not royalty.

Who’d have thought something this sophisticated, clever and witty would have come from a carefully fine-tuned and micromanaged to the nth degree movie from the Disney studios, but the screenwriter Chris Weitz (who has given us such fun bon bons as Antz and About a Boy) pulled off something of a coup in this particular scene.

Other than that, for my money, Cinderella is something of a mixed bag when it comes to success. I know it’s been socking it away at the box office, but I’m afraid that it only intermittently works for me.

 

I will say this, it’s certainly less white than many other attempts at this sort of thing (especially the more recent Into the Woods, which also includes the Cinderella story); minorities aren’t totally sent to the back of the bus. So it’s a step in the right direction, though I’m not sure that’s saying all that much still.

 

How you react to the film overall, though, will probably depend on how you feel about the dramatization of Cinderella’s through line, as well as Lilly James as our long suffering heroine. I found both to come up a bit short for my taste.

 

In contrast, the through line involving the Prince, or Kit as he is affectionately called, is much, much stronger and much, much more involving. Perhaps the most interesting success in this version is that, as the tale goes on, one doesn’t so much want Cinderella to end up in the arms of Kit for her sake as for his.

 

Kit’s father is dying and the King needs his son to marry for the good of the kingdom, and it needs to be royalty. Not only that, but the Grand Duke has already picked out who he thinks the boy should marry, the princess of a country that can be an advantageous alliance for Kit’s small kingdom (and for the Grand Duke personally)—and it’s a country that has a large army. If only the Grand Duke can manipulate the political intrigue with the cleverness of a Shakespearean character.

 

There is true warmth and emotional feeling between Kit and the King, much more so than between Cinderella and her father. And one does fear that the Prince may be coerced into making a terrible match.

 

At the same time, and as well as this works, the filmmakers don’t ultimately go all the way here as one might wish. Kit is never in any real danger, only in a fair amount of annoyance. When he wins, it’s with so little ramifications one wonders what all the brouhaha was about.

 

But in the end, it’s whenever Cinderella is more the center of the action that the story stalled for me.

 

The tale begins with a rather longish prolog summarizing, much of it through voice over, Cinderella’s childhood, the death of her mother and her father’s remarriage. Not enough time is really given to create a truly resonant set of relationships here. We’re told so much, rather than shown, that it really calls attention to itself.

 

And Cinderella’s story here doesn’t always make a lot of sense. Her step-mother resigns her to the attic and makes a servant of her as soon as her father leaves on a business trip. All I could think is what was going to happen when he gets back and discovers what his wife has done to someone he is so devoted to. Why the story doesn’t wait until after the father’s death seems a little odd to me.

 

In addition, Cinderella’s troubles are compounded by her step-mother not having any money, except that she does seem to have money at other times. It’s all rather vague and not that convincing.

 

And yes, I probably wouldn’t have thought about these issues if the movie was working for me, but I’m afraid it just wasn’t.

 

Even James, who is quite beautiful, felt a bit flat for me. That one scene in the woods with the Prince notwithstanding, I didn’t really feel there was that much there.

 

The best scenes here are actually with the step-sisters, who, this time round, are not made ugly, thank God, just given the characteristic of having ugly taste. Played by Sophie McShera (Daisy, the apprentice cook in Downton Abbey) and Holliday Grainger (she’s played Bonnie Parker and Lucrezia Borgia), they are given the most cutting of cutting dialog, lines that out snark Oscar Wilde and Noel Coward. And they deliver them with a relaxed laser pointer timing.

 

The evil step-mother is played, as anyone who has been on-line or in a movie theater for the last couple of months knows, by Cate Blanchett and she’s excellent, of course. At the same time, the writing leads to a rather strange moment.

 

Near the climax, Blanchett is given this long monolog that explains why she is the awful person she is. Okay, fine. Fair enough. And it’s a nice defense up to a point.

 

But as a friend pointed out, only a couple of lines later, Cinderella asks, “Why are you so cruel” and you so want Blanchett to tell her, “But weren’t you listening? I just told you. Didn’t you get the script pages before we shot the scene?”

 

This is piggy backed on an equally odd scene in which Cinderella is terrified to come down to the Prince in her ashy clothes and dirty face for fear he won’t want her for who she is. But all I could think is: “But he knows who you are. In fact, he fell in love with you knowing who you were. Am I missing something here?” And it is one of the more anti-climactic endings I’ve seen in awhile.

 

The direction is by Kenneth Branagh and though I think he’s done some fine work in the past, I don’t think he does a lot here. He’s much better when it comes to the personal scenes such as Kit and his father, or that beautiful scene in the woods (it reminded me of the scene between Kiera Knightly and Branagh himself in Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit, the best moment from that movie as well).

 

But for me, he really botches the ball scene and Cinderella’s entrance. It has nothing of the palpable emotion of Eliza Doolittle’s entrance in either My Fair Lady or Pygmalion. I always felt the camera was in the wrong place most of the time.

 

He isn’t helped in other scenes by what felt like well done, but not particularly imaginative CGI as when a pumpkin is turned into a carriage, some really annoying mice are turned into horses, a goose turned into a coachman, and lizards turned into footmen. It might have helped to have the complete song rather than the Fairy Godmother (Helena Bonham-Carter, who is also the narrator; she’s fine, but I’m not convinced she does anything that special with the character) only saying “bibbidi-bobbidi-boo” at one point.

 

With Robb Stark (I mean, Richard Madden) as the intensely handsome Kit; Derek Jacobi, very empathetic as the King; Stellan Skarsgard unrecognizable as the Grand Duke; Nonso Anozie (Daxos of Game of Thrones) as the Captain; and Ben Chaplin as Cinderella’s father.

 

 

 


3 Comments on “ASHES TO ASHES: Movie review of Cinderella by Howard Casner”

  1. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on to that Topic: rumblespoon.com/wp/2015/ashes-to-ashes-movie-review-of-cinderella-by-howard-casner/ […]

  2. DanielScurn says:

    http://interpharm.pro/# canada pharmacy world
    best online pharmacy india – internationalpharmacy.icu The staff always goes the extra mile for their customers.

  3. 9689 says:

    Maadonna aand lesbianDrinking bourbon and male ssex
    performanceSheer bikini pix teensEnormous boobs milfVagin monologue bostonHe boughht his fuckin buttonTeens fucked clipsAsian ladikes glsmour tgpNuddist
    girl pussy picsYukmon king vintage snowmobileFree sex role play storiesDe
    porn uman video yucatanFrree nude videeo women showeringExcited vaginaKeley hazel posinbg nudeVolleytball girls
    sexLump outsidee vaginal wallFrree full length facial moviesBooke porn star pissNamed ceoebrity femalesSttep
    brother andd step sistrer fucking inHod gayNude driving picturesKirstens room
    blowjobJulie andrews nakedBbw cream piie pussyCockk modificationsSexy woman wrestlingAdukt moovie evolutionThee eleephants listt adultTeeen imagebard picsArchhana puraan singh sex scenesNo memberhip webcam ssex https://bit.ly/3nhqQ6w Orlando vvip escortSexx
    potion for womenSins against ssex https://bit.ly/3xdTwSn Tinyy asian porn starFree
    bleach porn vieeo dowloadsBigg tittie blonndes getting fucked https://cutt.ly/ecsPjAh Passiflora blue stripperDigimon henta gamesS free
    fucking movies https://bit.ly/3qmtWrN Bonelless chickedn breasdt coating
    recipeGaay american gothicDownload irrsistible 1982 porn https://bit.ly/3oDZn1I Oh femdomm galleriesVinhtage hhasbro
    dollLauran tom nue https://cutt.ly/gU2Bx0K Cum on swimsuitsLatex wrappingCumm inn brunette hair https://bit.ly/35IcoNC Poorn mom teachin boysCasino poker stripAntique hobbies,
    vintage part toy toys, ttoy https://bit.ly/38K559I Crystal loiwe nuude movie clipSex drug addictsTight indian pussxy https://bit.ly/3HiCBD7 Accu chbeck active test strips1st
    black cockBaba desi hini in sexy story https://bit.ly/2SJDxcu Youyng young girls pornHardd teen orn moviesNatural list sex https://bit.ly/3obgKom Eating rraw penisJoohn anal washingtonCann bath salts cauise vaginal ain https://bit.ly/34yhr2l Mexcon pornDolly parton has bigg titsOppen vaginaa girls https://bit.ly/3qII8tQ Old guys teens blowjob videosFreee felicija cum fiesta movieSister flashes boobs https://bit.ly/3i61hFm Asian beetle allergy18 skinny pornFree twink bll boys https://tinyurl.com/2nmt5qy4 Erotic
    hupnotic teacherAmatdur gallry pic search thmb
    webScarlet johansopn sex slutlload https://bit.ly/3opHuDB Seezing
    heer titsPresidential report on pornographyHoow ro givbe a blow jjob https://tinyurl.com/yjb5mgsf Xxxx
    rated videotubesMy wife fucked thee carpenterComputer power strip aand liggted
    switches https://bit.ly/3zxIOYT Savnna dallas adult
    film starDisscharge panty from masturbationAsian law student https://bit.ly/34j6yVv Thick vibratorNympohet pornNaked wiife
    home photos https://bit.ly/3wxLUtH Moom teaching
    teen howAnal polrno bloopersSex srory blind voyeur https://bit.ly/2OMrbkY Nsfw
    videos sex small titAsian aadvanced guestbook 2.2Do sexy lyrics influence teen behavior https://bit.ly/34SlGWC Adult store inn arizonaOler aduult starsSoprabos best sexx scene
    https://tinyurl.com/yjk5sedh Coock heel igh tramplingDominztrix tampa escortCaning
    free spanking videdo xxx https://bit.ly/30vkGFV Filippino starr nudeEros ramazzotti –
    non siamo soliAnne taylor pantyhse https://bit.ly/2Ut9aecJamie lybn potn interviewAdult dday
    carre highland pardk ilAmature xxxx free vid https://bit.ly/3lvdTV2 Cum sucking whore named luci thaiFemale who suck blogHyppnotized ladis
    to fuck https://tinyurl.com/fkhmt2xw Yandy lingerieMaine adult edVintage cadillacs for sale https://bit.ly/3sQL2RV Cutte naked teen girlsFirst time teen videosLifting weights makes penis size
    smaller https://bit.ly/3xzuk90 Nuds iin kichenRoad sex homemase videosNc adult
    group https://cutt.ly/vU9lo6Q Vintage mercurfy outboard enginesViolkada xxxBiig ass
    booty shhaking viddeos https://bit.ly/357nxGS Blahk anamei pornIs gay marriag legaal in spainCourtney
    hansen nude images https://tinyurl.com/yxafw43n Fuuck all you motherfuckersGay
    lesbia organizations in 18951Teen twat 2010 jelspft enterpriises
    lttd https://tinyurl.com/ygpsc46p Workds bigvest ddick inFirswt
    time ccum shot storySexy comic book women pictures
    https://bit.ly/3xF9ULB Indin bane pussyVirtual girl naked97 ford
    escort serpentine belt https://tinyurl.com/47uvk5du Aduult videos
    free viewFamily guuy adult swim rooms in housePihay teen celebrity https://bit.ly/3liHIKN Bodybuilding
    blaack nudeHoot meexican ghrl getting fuckedVintage erotica forhm
    darrian https://cutt.ly/4JxwAHe Gay bars iin sqlt lakeAriso
    dickTeardrop bikini’s https://cutt.ly/QUJnVYD Easy recipes forr
    chihken breastLuciouus juicy pussy lipsAsijan films 2010 https://bit.ly/3j3pMUj Literotica
    mutual masturbationFucking at bassball practiuce red tubeAdult edjcation courdes in canberra https://bit.ly/3HLqQFf Older milfs with heavy hangers tubeAnal sex during periodGirl
    shboving stuhf in ass https://bit.ly/2Ti1wCY Tis pro facxial machineFirefox hentaiTennesee christiian teen convention https://tinyurl.com/2nsdqerb Sexyy ftee blpack girlsThumbnail gayH.o.t.
    Lingerie https://bit.ly/2VhGDJc Ninel conde ass spanked bby drunkardDaddy sexy storiesSpwrm donor silkbing registry https://tinyurl.com/kntp7j2n Naied native american womenMicckey gallagher naked iin shamelessNudde
    girls on boats https://bit.ly/34Yh01v Pirate ribbed brezsts strippedBliwjob mamaKiran sexy photos https://tinyurl.com/6tf46taw Jasmine pussyBra
    her lngerie pantiie uderwear undressAlabaster sex
    tube https://cutt.ly/gU4nrrj Mya harrion upskirtForced sex poprn picc galleriesBusty nylon babes https://tinyurl.com/y8pomx5w Hermaphrodite teensFreee howard sern adult xxx
    onlineMalle breast cancher pin https://tinyurl.com/yber6ps5 Blqck guhs gang bang white womanBdsm cartooningEscirt service
    brenda potter https://bit.ly/3ENPy70 John deere naked girlsFree english fuckingFrree pirn peeing videosGay teen porn on iphoneFree naked gay men picturesLacce strip club
    manhattanHoussewife porn frese moviesHot andd sexdy storiesAnal sex mucusSaly olivwr nakedGinsrng ssex maleLose your virgiknity testKardashian kim reviedw seex tapeBillabong megan trii pink bikinmi topTight
    pussy getting gangbangedIntervieww questions foor adult nursingItsyy
    bktsy tiie weennie teensLatex woman sexAllrite thumb buddyUnending be tossed dildoFree cockk teaswing storiesSeexy cordk wedgesGirls gettng mjltiple cumshotsMature nude videosBreast cancerr showed insurance problemsSwewt goilden assHott celeb
    upskirtsNakesd phat bootyNc female edotic dancers strippers picsOlder lesbian loversThe tudorts +
    nudfe photosSedal teenDeperate hohsewives nudeCrying pornstarsAnimke girls gefting spankedSex without condomn and camme
    into condomYvette hikgh protein diet pornSex aand the city scenhe namesFan fiction teen titansInstructional dvvd sexNaked pooping
    girlMutual ccumshot videosSeexy funny girlSisteer on sister anall fuckNia nude peeples photoFree erotic sex stories
    and textsFrree orn no memberships or downloadsGayy big orgyVideks sexy oor notUpskirt vvideo public


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *