POLITICAL THEATER: Movie reviews of Diplomacy, Viva la Liberta and Citizenfour

First, a word from our sponsors. Ever wonder what a reader for a contest or agency thinks when he reads your screenplay? Check out my new e-book published on Amazon: Rantings and Ravings of a Screenplay Reader, including my series of essays, What I Learned Reading for Contests This Year, and my film reviews of 2013. Only $2.99. http://ow.ly/xN31r

 

Warning: SPOILERS

diplomacyDid General von Choltitz, the Nazi governor of Paris during its final days of occupation, and Raul Nording, the Swedish counsul-general, really meet cute the night before von Choltitz was to blow up the major cultural buildings of Paris and cause the Seine to overflow and kill millions of people? And did Nording actually talk him out of doing so?

Some people say “yes”, some say “no”.

Of course, petty details like that have never stopped dramatists before (see Schiller having Mary, Queen of Scots confront Queen Elizabeth I). And either way, it’s hard not to see the potential for a fascinating confrontation and battle of minds.

So who cares if it really happened or not.

 

Unfortunately, when it comes to the new German film Diplomacy, written by director Volker Schlӧndorff (of The Tin Drum and The Handmaid’s Tale) and Cyril Gely, who penned the play the film is based on, the two haven’t quite succeeded in fulfilling said potential. In fact, Diplomacy, with all its weighty subject matter, never manages to generate a lot of tension or forward momentum.

 

And this in spite of the fact that the filmmakers have eschewed Roman Polanski’s approach in his theatrical film adaptations, such as The God of Carnage and Venus in Furs, in which that director basically just recorded a stage play (with a lot of flare and fun in the latter film it should be said; not so much in the former).

 

Instead, Schlӧndorff and Gely don’t just dramatize the confrontation of von Choltitz and Nording, they also open up the story and generate a more action oriented, ticking time bomb (pardon he pun) through line by dramatizing some events that include the soldiers setting the explosives.

 

But neither part of the story really works as well as one might like.

 

These additional scenes, the soldiers setting the explosives, never feel convincing and come across as what they are…an attempt to create a more audience friendly movie rather than moments that organically grow out of the characters and situation (and begs the question, if you didn’t trust the source material, then why adapt it).

 

And the scenes with von Choltitz and Nording sort of limp along because there is very little of dramatic weight in their meeting. Which, yes, seems odd, but there you have it.

 

When Nording first sneaks into von Choltitz’s hotel room through a secret passageway a King once had made so he could visit his mistress (I told you they meet cute), the story doesn’t go anywhere because there really isn’t much of an argument. Von Choltitz is going to do as ordered and the only reason he gives is because he’s a soldier and soldiers obey orders.

 

Well, okay, but since there’s really not much you can say in argument against that, Nording isn’t left with anything to say and he proceeds not to say it. There’s no real intellectual battle of any interest here, no grand and passionate argument because there really can’t be. Von Choltitz has nothing at stake in the conflict, not even a guilty conscience or his self-worth as a human being.

 

Von Choltitz is so dead set on obeying orders, there’s no place for the conflict to go.

 

The only thing that can happen here is a robust and original and intellectually stimulating argument between the two characters and that really doesn’t happen. No one has anything of that great interest to say.

 

It’s not until the second half that it’s revealed that there actually is something at stake for the general and that is his wife and children who are being held semi-prisoners in case von Choltitz doesn’t obey orders. And at this point, the story does pick up some interest and there is some suspense, but the arguments and battle of wills don’t get much better.

 

All we have are the rather clunky, overly familiar and even clichéd action scenes.

 

It also may not help that the audience knows what the ending is. I mean, we all are fully aware (unless you are the product of the American education system, then who knows what you know) that Paris wasn’t destroyed and that von Choltitz didn’t give the orders.

 

So if we know the ending ahead of time, which means there’s no inherent suspense, there has to be something else going on to keep our interest up and I’m afraid there just wasn’t for me.

 

With the great Niels Arestrup, who first burst on the scene over here in such films as The Beat that My Heart Skipped and A Prophet, as von Choltitz, and Andre Klaussner, who has been in everything from Amelie to Tell No One to Micmacs, as Nording. Both of them recreate the roles they played on stage.

 

viva la libertaI suppose that if we, over here in the good old U.S. of A., can make a movie like Dave (you know, the one where Kevin Kline, a presidential impersonator, ends up impersonating the president), then the Italians have every right to make a movie like Viva la libertà (Long Live Freedom).

 

In this film written by Angelo Pasquini and the director Robert Andó (who also wrote the book the movie is based on), Enrico, the head of a major party in Italy (which party might be clearer if one is Italian, but it looked like the liberals and/or Communists) is the head of said (or not said, as I said, it’s a bit unclear) party because, well, because there really isn’t anyone else right now.

 

You see, Italy has been in decline for some time and Enrico’s party, the one that is supposed to stand for the workers and the common man, has let their followers down by not having a clear message or vision for the future. They are losing the respect of their party members because they have nothing to offer and, perhaps even worse, Enrico doesn’t have the personality to not offer it and still keep the party going.

 

So he takes off. Just disappears. There’s some indication he did it to prove to all and sundry that they can’t get along without him. But at any rate, he knows that things aren’t going well and he needs to get away, so he looks up an old girlfriend (wispy voiced Valeria Bruni Tedeschi, who seems to be in every other Italian film these days) from his earlier days when he was interested in film.

 

She lives in Paris now with her film director husband and little girl and she takes him in, no questions asked.

 

So what’s a party to do? Well, Enrico’s disappearance leads his number two man, Andrea, to Enrico’s twin brother Giovanni. The solution to their situation: bide time by having Giovanni take Enrico’s place. The problem: Giovanni, a philosopher and author, has just gotten out of a mental institution. The result: while Enrico gloomily leads his life in Paris trying to find himself, Giovanni is so charismatic with a delightful personality and a commanding presence, that he is able to rally his party and bring them together to fight for a better future.

 

Viva la Liberta is often fun and funny. And droll. It’s also often rather droll at times.

 

This is mainly because of Toni Servillo’s performance as the twin brothers. Servillo is one of Italy’s greatest actors (if not the greatest) and one of the finest in the world. He is able to give strong individual characters to each brother, while still making it believable that no one can tell them apart. He shows great empathy as Enrico and makes you understand why Giovanni could rally the troops, so to speak.

 

His performance is more than aided and abetted by Valeria Mastandrea as Andrea.   There is something so soulful and lost in Mastandrea’s sad eyes and wistful looks (characteristics he also showed as the lost son in the movie The First Beautiful Things) that one can’t help but be emotionally invested as he realizes that he hopes that Enrico never returns.

 

The movie never really comes together, though, as strongly as it might. First, one has to buy the plot turn that in a country that gave us the word paparazzi, no one has ever heard of this twin brother who published a book.

 

And the politics seem a little too vague. The party is letting their followers down because they have nothing to offer them, no real future, no ideas, no platform.

 

But neither does Giovanni. He gives a great speech. He’s inspiring. Once can easily see why he excites the people.

 

The problem is that he also has nothing to say. He also has no ideas, no platform, nothing to offer them. He’s just better at saying it in a way that gets the people on his side. As a result, his speeches become sort of repetitive and empty and start to lose tension and meaning.

 

And I’m not convinced that was the point of the movie, that it’s a mocking and tongue in cheeck comment on a party whose solution is not to change and become a real political movement, but to find someone who can get people on their side even though they have nothing to say.

 

You know, like the Republicans have been trying to do.

 

In the end, this is a political satire that is both sharp and blunt. And I’m not sure that’s to the benefit of the movie.

 

citizenfourCitizenfour is a documentary about Edward Snowden, the computer geek turned folk hero who leaked national security documents about our government collecting personal information on its own citizens, as well as populaces of almost every country on the planet (including, but not limited to, German Chancellor Angela Merkel), and who ended up taking political asylum in Russia.

 

It’s the sort of movie that outrages you, or should (and it does, at least as long as one is in the theater), as it demonstrates the possibility of a George Orwellian future. Perhaps the only thing keeping us safe right now is that so much information is being gathered that no entity can really wade through it on a regular basis—that, and the at times gang who couldn’t shoot straight incompetent nature of our various national security agencies.

 

Neither caveats fill me with that much comfort right now.

 

The first half or more of the movie is mainly just the camera focused on Snowden himself as he talks and talks and talks…and talks. Now I’m sure that if I met him in real life, I suspect he would be a great guy to sit around with and have a beer. But as someone who has a camera strictly focused on him, he’s not the most charismatic of characters. These parts don’t have a lot of tension and tend to meander on.

 

What is really odd here is that when Snowden first speaks, he tells director Laura Poitras that he is afraid that if it is revealed too soon who it is who is blowing the whistle on what the NSA et al. is really up to, that the story will become about him. But in many ways, by so focusing on Snowden, that’s sort of what Poitras does (for the record, Snowden is a bit vain and is constantly confounded by his hair which just won’t lay right no matter how much mouse he uses).

 

The strongest aspects of the documentary are when the film gets away from that claustrophobic hotel room and shows how the leaks are affecting the rest of the world: reporter Glenn Greenwald reuniting with his Brazilian boyfriend after the boyfriend is held and questioned for nine hours; the newspapers trying to figure out what they can print and what they can’t; the various speaking engagements the characters have trying to explain just what is going on and how the government is working with various internet sites (like facebook, apple, google, etc.); Obama’s unconvincing and weak response to Snowden’s actions; and a hearing with a former NSA analyst that was stopped when it was discovered there was a CIA double agent in the meeting.

 

Perhaps what is saddest about the movie is the unintentional implication that Snowden and the involvement of the NSA in spying on its citizens is just another flavor of the month. He’s come, he’s gone and no one’s really talking about him much or what the various U.S. security agencies are doing or whether we should stop them (at least, my facebook thread hasn’t had much to say about it lately).

 

I mean, after all, when all is said and done, much of the talk about Citizenfour these days is not its content and what it means, but whether it will win best documentary at the Oscars this year.

 

 

 

 


16 Comments on “POLITICAL THEATER: Movie reviews of Diplomacy, Viva la Liberta and Citizenfour”

  1. xmc.pl says:

    I appreciate your work , appreciate it for all the informative content .

  2. Hi I just dropped by and wanted to say you to have a Merry Christmas. Let all your wishes make come true for you and your family and lets hope the next year be prosperous for all us.Merry Christmas

  3. Alelianny says:

    Customs Service coupons for cialis 20 mg Read on to discover how you can purchase Cialis safely and securely online with no hassle

  4. Adottejed says:

    com or call the number on your health plan ID card to see your PDL and get specific information about your pharmacy benefits where can i buy priligy in usa Il farmaco puГІ essere utilizzato per un lungo periodo di tempo, in particolare se non causa effetti collaterali o effetti allergici e ha gli effetti previsti

  5. expelty says:

    My lettering work has been seen in Marvel Comics, Image Comics, Dark Horse Comics, Playboy, and books by other publishers, but these days, my lettering and logos can mostly be found in and on comics published by Image Comics best cialis online

  6. EvovaHive says:

    Under the terms of the agreement, Sanofi is buying the exclusive rights to apply for approval of Cialis tablets over the counter in the United States, Europe, Canada and Australia canadian pharmacy cialis

  7. Drypeteek says:

    choosing not to take tamoxifen Anecdotally, the breast cancer patients treated with the hpta.

  8. axioste says:

    You can support this great cause by volunteering, shopping, or donating to Revivals or directly to DAP Health. unidox solutab in usa

  9. Clicymn says:

    stromectol france Gabriella, USA 2022 06 17 13 05 21

  10. Playept says:

    does tamoxifen make you tired In all cases, an oral AI either exemestane 25 mg, or letrozole 2

  11. Burcisk says:

    B Percent cystic area relative to total kidney area of kidneys from Pkd1 nl nl mice treated with AZ505 n 12 or DMSO n 12 doxycycline std com 20 E2 AD 90 20Calcium 20Channel 20Blockers 20Viagra 20 20Viagra 20Sildenafil 20Citrate 20100mg calcium channel blockers viagra One week after having just one ball thrown to him, Nicks was thrown to nine times on Sunday

  12. cittyunit says:

    As said earlier, Diz casino offers some of the best interesting online casino games. Players can make a choice amongst the well-known casino options. Also, if you search as per major categories, you can have a better score. There are many slot machines and also table games diversity that you can enjoy. The operator offers a good live casino section where you can find some amazing variations in the live dealer game. GRATOWIN CASINO gives a exclusive welcome bonus with $ €7 no deposit casino bonus on sign up. Just sign up an account and you get $ €7 in free bonus no deposit are required for this bonus. When you have take your free gift and played with it and you are ready for more action, then you have a 100% casino bonus up to $ €200 waiting for you The casino accepts strictly adult players from eighteen (18) years of age. It is the player’s sole responsibility to inquire about the existing laws and regulations of the given jurisdiction regarding age limitations for online gambling. https://tysongwkz986421.qodsblog.com/14124895/3-pound-deposit-slots Once you have registered an account, you can start betting on games using your bitcoin. Start betting on more than 140 sports types with our sportsbook and 5,000+ casino games by claiming your $500 worth of bitcoin welcome bonus. You may choose from our selection of bets once you have logged in. Winnings and withdrawals are processed instantly.. Gcash is a popular e-wallet in the Philippines because it allows its users to link their accounts to PayPal or credit cards including Mastercard. With this option, customers can easily cash in their funds or winnings from sportsbooks and other gaming websites. An important feature of this e-wallet is its ability to be linked to PayPal, a popular online wallet that’s used by sports bettors and casino players. With the service, you can easily move your funds from PayPal to your e-wallet using your first and last name of the account. To make it happen, you need to link your account with PayPal with Gcash.

  13. Lutrago says:

    紧张刺激的德州扑克锦标赛 传奇扑克作为国内首屈一指的赛事服务商,先后举办了小饭桌全国创投扑克大赛、 mpt移动互联网行业扑克巡回赛、“创新杯”创新工场扑克比赛、真格基金红杉资本扑克友谊赛等赛事,基奠 GPI年度最佳选手(GPI PoY)是颁发给在一个自然年中参与现场锦标赛中取得最好成绩选手的奖项。 #21 深筹赛部分参赛选手照片 事实上,这两家公司今年的适应性比大多数人要好。通过现场赛事、非现场替代和混合锦标赛的组合,现在2021年的前景远比过去一段时间更乐观。 扑克传奇是中国德州扑克第一媒体及行业赛事运营商,已获多位著名投资人联合投资 北京· IT 互联网 · 20-99人 工商信息查看更多 成立时间2014-12-31注册资本法人代表裴微 扑克传奇的面试经历查看全 https://zanevkbp643198.blogunok.com/14450193/百-家-樂-九州 苹果的德州扑克又回来了!为了庆祝App Store成立10周年,我们带回了其首批游戏之一,一款颇受欢迎的经典游戏。最初是为iPod制作,然后带到iPhone,粉丝们会喜欢抛光的重新设计,包括新角色,更具挑战性的游戏玩法,以及支持最新iPhone和iPod touch的精美图像。玩家第一次免费玩的话也会喜欢它。 欢乐德州扑克app让你能够获得众多的游戏功能,玩家可以和你的好朋友一起约会,在这里建造私人房间,调整游戏中的游戏规则,让你们玩到最经典的棋牌游戏。 喜欢这种风格游戏的玩家们,不妨下载欢乐德州扑克app畅玩一下吧! 「鲍老儿」,淳正之态。果然道:百宝装腰带,珍珠络 换换现金的棋牌游戏 元神天仙境


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *